Great Eastern Cutlery Sunfish Knife
Great Eastern Cutlery Sunfish w/ stag

This pocket knife pattern is very popular and highly sought after among collectors.  This pattern goes by the sunfish, elephant toenail or just toenail knife.  These knives are extremely beefy and were meant for rough and tough use.  The master blade is super thick and wide and usually features two pulls (a nail nick and long pull).  They usually feature a large secondary pen blade as well.  Some of the most collectible sunfish patterns were made by Case, Cattaraugus and Hibbard, Spencer, Bartlett & Co.

Check out these vintage Sunfish Knives that are currently available on eBay I appreciate any traffic from these links as I earn a portion of eBay’s commission when an item is purchased, at no extra cost to you. THANK YOU!!! – Jesse, oldpocketknives.com

Most popular

Old Case Bros Little Valley Tested XX Toenail Sunfish Pocket Knife Knives

$6,999.99  
End Date: Monday Aug-03-2020 16:49:49 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $6,999.99
Buy It Now

1979 1 Dot Case XX 6250 Bradford Bonanza Elephant Toe Knife Pakkawood Handles

$142.50  (22 bids)
End Date: Friday Jul-10-2020 21:40:09 EDT

Bid

CASE BROTHERS LITTLE VALLEY NY SUNFISH KNIFE TESTED XX

$2,400.00  
End Date: Friday Jul-24-2020 01:55:20 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $2,400.00
Buy It Now

CASE BROTHERS LITTLE VALLEY NY. 1900-12 5250 SUNFISH OR TOENAIL STAG HANDLE

$1,000.00  
End Date: Thursday Jul-16-2020 01:57:09 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $1,000.00
Buy It Now

Case Tested Sunfish Elephant Toe Jigged Bone Rare Pocket Knife 1920-40

$695.00  
End Date: Friday Aug-07-2020 21:05:59 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $695.00
Buy It Now

Case xx 40-64 Elephant Toe Knife Jigged Red Bone Near Mint 6250

$769.95  
End Date: Friday Jul-17-2020 14:06:16 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $769.95
Buy It Now

Case Tested XX 6250 mint green bone sunfish elephant toe 1920-40 era mint knife

$2,400.00  
End Date: Wednesday Jul-22-2020 13:30:26 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $2,400.00
Buy It Now

C PLATTS & SONS TOENAIL SUNFISH KNIFE

$3,200.00  
End Date: Thursday Jul-30-2020 15:50:22 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $3,200.00
Buy It Now

Lot 25 - Bulldog 1995 2-Blade, Stag, Sunfish LE 54 of 112 Knife w/Box

$73.00  (11 bids)
End Date: Friday Jul-10-2020 14:37:01 EDT

Bid

SCHATT & MORGAN (QUEEN)#100 Sunfish WHITTLER Jumbo WHITE BONE Knife and Box USA

$77.00  (2 bids)
End Date: Friday Jul-10-2020 13:09:26 EDT

Bid

WINCHESTER SUNFISH KNIFE - JIGGED BONE - 29110 1/2 - RIFLE SERIES - NIB

$129.99  
End Date: Monday Aug-03-2020 13:53:35 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $129.99
Buy It Now

Case 1976 4 Dot 6250 Elephant Toe Knife

$225.00  
End Date: Sunday Jul-19-2020 12:07:34 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $225.00
Buy It Now

Rare Vintage Antique ~ CASE XX TESTED ?? ~ 2 Blade Sunfish Elephant Toe Knife

$150.00  (1 bid)
End Date: Tuesday Jul-14-2020 15:59:40 EDT

Bid

Rare Bulldog Brand GEC Sunfish Elephant Toe Red Abalone Pocket Knife 1 Of 50

$499.00  
End Date: Sunday Aug-02-2020 19:19:15 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $499.00
Buy It Now

Vtg 1995 Bulldog Brand Prototype Elephant Toenail Sunfish Knife In Case

$274.95  
End Date: Thursday Jul-30-2020 00:39:16 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $274.95
Buy It Now

CUSTOM JOEL CHAMBLIN BROWN BONE SUNFISH KNIFE

$1,349.00  
End Date: Tuesday Jul-28-2020 14:02:48 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $1,349.00
Buy It Now

GEC #46 Whaler Sunfish Knife Tidioute Muscle Bone 462218 Great Eastern Cutlery

$799.95  
End Date: Monday Jul-20-2020 23:03:56 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $799.95
Buy It Now

GEC #26 Sleeveboard Watch Pocket Sunfish Knife Stag 262209 Great Eastern Cutlery

$299.95  
End Date: Friday Aug-07-2020 17:30:51 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $299.95
Buy It Now

1995 Fight'N Rooster Elephant Toe Illinois Knife, 4" Closed, # 011 of 100

$128.00  
End Date: Thursday Jul-23-2020 11:58:15 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $128.00
Buy It Now

case xx custom sunfish elephant toe knife 6270leather sheath 1998 MOP limited

$550.00  
End Date: Thursday Jul-16-2020 21:49:41 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $550.00
Buy It Now

FRANK BUSTER FIGHT N ROOSTER BLACK & WHITE ELEPHANT SUNFISH TOE NAIL KNIFE RARE

$209.99  
End Date: Sunday Aug-02-2020 01:28:45 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $209.99
Buy It Now

Schatt & Morgan by Queen-Keystone Series XII-142265-1/600-Baby Sunfish-2002

$159.95  
End Date: Saturday Jul-25-2020 22:58:53 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $159.95
Buy It Now

GEC #46 Whaler Sunfish Knife Tidioute Ironwood 462218 Great Eastern Cutlery wood

$799.95  
End Date: Monday Jul-13-2020 00:02:02 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $799.95
Buy It Now

Bulldog Giant 8.5" Display Sunfish Knife Crystal Synthetic/Bluegill Etch 1 of 10

$799.95  
End Date: Wednesday Jul-29-2020 15:45:21 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $799.95
Buy It Now

GEC #36 Sunfish Knife American Patriot Acrylic 1095 362112 Great Eastern Cutlery

$374.95  
End Date: Saturday Aug-01-2020 16:15:32 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $374.95
Buy It Now

Marbles Sunfish / Elephant Toe Knife MR 113 Brand New Old Stock!

$89.99  
End Date: Friday Jul-10-2020 12:54:03 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $89.99
Buy It Now

Marbles MR113 Large Sunfish/Ele-Toe Folder Knife -NOS/NO POUCH!

$69.89  
End Date: Friday Jul-24-2020 23:06:53 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $69.89
Buy It Now

GEC #36 Sunfish Knife Northfield A.W. Jig Bone 1095 362208 Great Eastern Cutlery

$399.95  
End Date: Friday Jul-31-2020 16:05:48 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $399.95
Buy It Now

C. 1911 Robeson Excellent Swell Center Double End Jack Sunfish 622409

$675.00  
End Date: Monday Jul-20-2020 12:42:45 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $675.00
Buy It Now

Ka-bar UNION CUT. CO. SF86 SUNFISH Elephant's Toenail knife

$159.95  
End Date: Sunday Aug-02-2020 10:31:31 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $159.95
Buy It Now

Schatt & Morgan Queen USA Baby Sunfish 1 Of 30 Made Rare Pocket Knife Stag NOS.

$125.00  (1 bid)
End Date: Friday Jul-10-2020 11:29:59 EDT

Bid

CATTARAGUS CUTLERY CO USA BONE HANDLE SUNFISH KNIFE with 2 blades

$350.00  
End Date: Friday Jul-10-2020 21:23:21 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $350.00
Buy It Now

Turquoise Smith & Wesson Sunfish / Elephant Toe Knife 1997 USA HANDMADE!

$389.99  
End Date: Friday Jul-31-2020 15:25:17 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $389.99
Buy It Now

GEC #46 Whaler Sunfish Knife Northfield Ebony Wood 462213 Great Eastern Cutlery

$799.95  
End Date: Sunday Jul-26-2020 16:26:13 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $799.95
Buy It Now

GEC #46 Whaler Sunfish Knife Tidioute Muscle Bone 462218 EDC/Recessed Shield**

$699.95  
End Date: Monday Jul-13-2020 00:02:03 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $699.95
Buy It Now

GEC #36 Sunfish Knife Tidioute Burnt Grizzly 1095 362208 Great Eastern Cutlery

$399.95  
End Date: Thursday Jul-16-2020 03:10:40 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $399.95
Buy It Now

WILBERT CUTLERY CO SUNFISH KNIFE

$775.00  
End Date: Monday Jul-20-2020 18:29:57 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $775.00
Buy It Now

1995 Case Classic Prototype Crystal Caramel Sunfish Knife! BEYOND SUPER RARE!

$329.95  
End Date: Friday Aug-07-2020 22:14:36 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $329.95
Buy It Now

CLASSIC WINCHESTER BRNT ORANGE RIFLE SERIES SUNFISH TOE NAIL USA KNIFE w CASE NM

$199.99  
End Date: Friday Aug-07-2020 22:18:44 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $199.99
Buy It Now

Winchester USA 1996 29110 buffalo head Knife MINT/BOX-ELEPHANT TOE/SUNFISH

$79.99  (1 bid)
End Date: Saturday Jul-11-2020 23:19:43 EDT

Bid

Case XX USA Lightning SS 1980 10 Dot Bradford Bonanza 6250 Elephant Toe Nail

$139.00  
End Date: Tuesday Aug-04-2020 21:50:22 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $139.00
Buy It Now

Ka-Bar Union Razor Co Sunfish 1986 Collectors Club 3 Elephants Toenail Knife Set

$449.95  
End Date: Thursday Aug-06-2020 12:42:49 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $449.95
Buy It Now

Pen Slip Sleeve Black Elephant 4 TiBolt Nottingham TuffWriter Hinderer EDC Pens

$89.00  
End Date: Thursday Jul-16-2020 19:44:21 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $89.00
Buy It Now

GEC #26 Sleeveboard Watch Pocket Sunfish Knife Wood 262212 Great Eastern Cutlery

$299.95  
End Date: Tuesday Jul-14-2020 14:32:28 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $299.95
Buy It Now

1996 Bulldog GENUINE AMAZING THICK STAG Sunfish Knife ELK Etch BEAUTIFUL STAG!

$369.00  
End Date: Monday Jul-20-2020 15:24:18 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $369.00
Buy It Now

WINCHESTER,1997, # 29112BH TOENAIL ~ SUNFISH KNIFE, BURNT ORANGE BONE, MINT

$125.00  
End Date: Sunday Jul-12-2020 20:30:57 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $125.00
Buy It Now

Case XX WRC 2009 Red Jig Bone Sunfish Knife Stainless Steel Large 4,5" USA Made

$199.95  
End Date: Thursday Jul-16-2020 03:10:40 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $199.95
Buy It Now

Vintage Wilbert Elephant Toenail pocket knife

$325.00  
End Date: Sunday Jul-12-2020 20:44:38 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $325.00
Buy It Now

WINCHESTER,2010,# 29110 TOENAIL ~ SUNFISH KNIFE, BUFFALO HEAD SHIELD, NICE NM

$106.25  
End Date: Thursday Aug-06-2020 22:47:52 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $106.25
Buy It Now

Old Timer Shrade "Sunfish" Lockback Knife

$129.95  
End Date: Thursday Jul-23-2020 16:49:09 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $129.95
Buy It Now

More Sunfish knives